Duke coach Kara Lawson, talking to her team:
“Don’t give external people the power to touch you that way. You control that. Don’t let me control whether you are going to have a good day or not, or if you feel good about yourself, or if you feel validated.”
My way of doing that is a scoreboard.
Imposter syndrome comes from not having a scoreboard.
Find the data, and you stop needing other people to tell you you’re good.
I spend most of my time coming up with new ideas and putting them out for public scrutiny. So how do I know if I’m good at that?
It’s easy to look at followers. But followers can be insanely devoid of engagement. Seer’s LinkedIn page has roughly the same number of followers as I do. I’ve looked at influential people in our industry with the same follower count as me, and their most engaged posts just don’t perform as well.
So here’s my scoreboard:
- Do I get invited back to speak after I speak? How long does it take them to ask?
- If a conference is new, do I gain followers?
- How does each post do against my own other posts on the same platform? (I never blame the algorithm, I’m ceeding power to them if I say, oh it’s the algorithm).
- Does the value of my activities outweigh my cost to the company? (I use things like CPCs for keywords, CPMs for LinkedIn Thought leader posts, etc, so I’m not using numbers that anyone could say “well wil, what is an impression worth?” I’ve already had an agent calculate based on deep research what it would cost a company to get my organic impressions.
This is the type of scoreboard you need – and then you just need to be brutally honest with yourself when the scoreboard says… you ain’t doing so hot.
Sometimes I look and go, man, my last 10 posts are 50% under my average from last year. I just don’t have great ideas right now. I’m not doing my job as well as I used to.
What I don’t need is someone inside the company saying “Wil, your stuff isn’t hitting, bro.” I already know. And I don’t need someone telling me I crushed it either.
FAILURE is part of the game
You’re always going to have failures. Look at your scoreboard the way an athlete looks at missed shots or incompletions.
Say you’ve had 10 clients at your company. Do you know the average retention or upsell rate? Let’s say 30% of clients get upsold within 12 months. If your clients upsell more, renew faster, or stay longer than average, that’s your answer.
Sometimes you lose a client because they can’t implement. You could say that’s not your fault. Someone else might say: what makes me feel great about my job is that when clients can’t get things done, I have a really high rate of showing them the true value and changing their minds.
Know your COST
I’m fanatical about this, and it’s really gotten under Crystal’s skin. I’m often one of the top three highest paid people at Seer. Technically not the last 2 years, because I leave the profits in the business and only bring home my salary. That aside, I’ve always built a scoreboard to make sure my contribution is greater than my cost.
Wouldn’t you want to know that about yourself? Now you’re getting ahead of the layoff. If the data says you’re good, great. If it says you’re not, that’s an opportunity, because now you know what to improve.
BATTLE TEST it
It’s human nature to want to feel good at your job. So be honest with yourself and get other perspectives. Don’t use peers. Use a CFO, a controller, or a COO. And not a cheerleader. You want someone who’ll say, “According to these numbers, you’re middle of the pack.”
Now the scary part. Say your scoreboard has been battle tested, the data says you’re good, and you still believe you’re not. That means you can convince yourself of something in spite of the evidence.
How is that any different from a flat earther or an anti-vaxxer? Believing something in spite of evidence is not a place I’d want to be.


























